Book Review: The Element by Sir Ken Robinson
30 Nov
Although it was Elizabeth Gilbert’s TED talk [1] that turned me into a TED [2] enthusiast, up to this day my most favorite TED talk remains Sir Ken Robinson’s on how school kills creativity [3]. The talk introduced me to the work and thoughts of Sir Ken Robinson, and I was brimming with joy to find that he shares the same ideas as I do on the topic of education. Of course, this meant that I went on to find more of his content online and eventually purchased his seminal book, The Element [4].
Sir Ken Robinson [5] is a leading thinker on the subject of creativity and education. His life work has led him around the globe, giving talks worldwide on the current educational crisis and the solution we can take to solve it. He has worked with individuals and institutions alike, with businesses and governments all over the world, and he has been endowed with knighthood for his achievements in his field.
What’s most interesting, is that Sir Ken Robinson suffered polio when he was less than five years old. This experience would’ve left many other children and their parents fall into the valley of despair and declare that the boy’s future is ruined – but that didn’t happen in the case of the Robinsons. Sir Ken opted to focus on strengthening his mental assets, causing him to be accepted and acknowledged by advanced educational institutions, and he continued on to become an authority himself.
Finding your Element
The main body of The Element talks about the importance of finding what our passion in life is. It is important because not only does our self happiness rely on the alignment between what we do for a living and what our true talents are, the very sustainability and welfare of our communities and culture also rely on the individual and collective strengths of people who tap their elemental energies. In the book, Sir Ken Robinson conducts numerous interviews and research into the lives and lessons of many prominent figures in current and past societies, and found that many of these figures discovered their own element through self thought and made their own way to reach whatever it is that is most natural for them to pursue.
Which brings us to the topic of education: in the concluding chapters of the book, Sir Ken Robinson explains the damage conformity to conventional education has on our society, and promotes that we should transform education to acknowledge the individual strengths in every person and encourage it in order for these individuals to become high achievers in their lives who have an organic understanding of themselves and their environments and also be able to contribute well to the progress of their communities. This strikes a particular chord with me – more now than when I first read the book – because I too think and have seen that many of my friends and people in the community around me place too much power on conforming with social expectations and official high level educational institutions. Now, I’m a graduate of one of these institutions myself – and I was a successful participant of the industrial method of education – but I dropped the paradigm the moment I learned that success and happiness for me has no significant relation to the level of formal education I achieved or what multinational corporation I work for.
Especially in my country – Indonesia, which is still considered a developing country – the emphasis on being an employee and working for a well known established company is the main aspiration parents have for their children and the main motivation the children study hard for their exams (if they’re even interested that is; many children are disenfranchised by this method of living and learning). The problem that arises from this social mis-construct is that many children feel they are not good enough (since they under-perform in school testing) and therefore assume they do not have their place in society other than being “the common folk”. When instead, simply using a different paradigm and a different social construct, these same children could eventually grow up to be artists, dancers, painters, innovators, community leaders, social entrepreneurs, and reach their own independence through self reliance and autonomy.
The other climate crisis
This space is not enough to explain how much of an advocate I am of being authentic; and how much I view organic education as being an inherent and critically important part of that. The prominent people who have achieved success and fulfillment are often the people who find their education after and inspite of formal education in schools. They find their true calling after they dropped out or after they go through a post graduation identity crisis.
But must that be the only way we can discover our true identities and our true passions? Must we barter the first 16 to 25 years of our lives for the freedom of our identity? Is that the price we must pay to learn what it is that makes us happy – by going through a system that teaches us what makes us unhappy? The formal education system that still stands today is a product from the industrial era and was made for industrial purposes: to produce factory workers in an assembly line method of approach. Now we are entering the knowledge worker era [6] where self reliance, autonomy, and self learning are all critical to find our place in society and achieve physical and emotional success.
An analogy would be this: now that cellphones are here, how would you feel if you were still forced to use land-line telephones – the ones that have dials on them? Sure you can still use them, but their efficiency, reliability, and accessibility are made obsolete with cellular technology. This is how I view standardized formal education has become: an obsolete technology that had its use during the day, but now it’s time to move forward to the technology that is appropriate for us and especially for our children, who will face a future where the technology they use as everyday part of their lives are not even here yet. The system needs to be changed, the paradigm needs to be corrected, and the stakeholders need to be involved; we are in an educational crisis, and like the environment, if we don’t take action soon, we end up endangering the very survivability of humanity.
Do you agree that education needs to be transformed, as Sir Ken Robinson writes? Share your thoughts on the current education system, its benefits and flaws, and share what you think would be the solution for future education.
—
*I also spent the month of November re-reading and curating quotes from The Element. Have a look HERE if you’re interested.
*IMPORTANT NOTE: I am moving the blog to a sub-domain of my site. If you have subscribed by RSS, please change your feed subscription to the new site. Thank you.
[1] Book Review: Eat Pray Love, 2009
[2] TED Official website
[3] Sir Ken Robinson on TED
[4] The Element, by Sir Ken Robinson
[5] Sir Ken Robinson Official website
[6] The term knowledge worker is borrowed from Stephen Covey’s The 8th Habit



THE SIDE-STORY